Loxone or KNX for a family house? Miniserver, Tree and KNX manufacturers (Gira, MDT) explained for homeowners
Loxone and KNX are both wired smart home systems: lighting, shading and heating run in one system, on cable, not radio. The difference lies in the architecture. Loxone is one manufacturer’s system, with its logic running in a central controller, the Miniserver. KNX is an open standard in which devices from hundreds of manufacturers (such as Gira and MDT) work together, with no single central unit. We install both; this article helps you decide which suits your house.
In short
- Loxone: one manufacturer, one central unit (Miniserver), its own bus (Tree) and its own app. Quick to set up, with visualisation built in.
- KNX: an open standard (EN 50090, ISO/IEC 14543-3), hundreds of manufacturers, decentralised: every device decides for itself. The system is independent of any one manufacturer or installer.
- Cabling: both need a decision before plastering. The 230 V circuits run in a star to the distribution board, next to them the Loxone Tree or KNX bus cable.
- Gira, MDT: two of the many KNX manufacturers. In one KNX system they can be mixed, even in the same switch frame.
- Decision: if you want one manufacturer and one app, Loxone is convenient; if you plan for 20–30 years, independent of manufacturer and installer, KNX is the safer choice.
Author: Norbert Madarász
, Managing Director and Partner · Updated: 14 November 2026
What is the Loxone system? Miniserver, Tree, Air and Link
At the heart of a Loxone house is the Miniserver: a DIN-rail controller in the distribution board. All the logic runs in it (what switches what, when and under which conditions); we programme it with the manufacturer’s Loxone Config software, and the smartphone app connects to it. Devices connect in four ways:
- Tree: Loxone’s own wired bus for push-buttons, sensors and lights. Data and 24 V power run in one cable. According to the manufacturer, one branch may have at most 50 Tree devices and at most 500 m of cable, considerably less with high-power devices (Tree lights, dimmers) because of voltage drop; it recommends starting with no more than about 35 devices per cable to leave room for extensions.
- Link: the Miniserver’s extension modules (such as relay and Tree extensions) connect on this bus inside the board.
- Air: Loxone’s wireless devices, for places no cable can reach later.
- Network and other systems: the Miniserver also talks to other devices over the network cable. The second-generation Miniserver no longer has KNX built in; the manufacturer offers a separate KNX Extension for this (up to 500 KNX group addresses according to its datasheet).
How is KNX different?
KNX has no central brain: every push-button, actuator and sensor has its own programme and sends messages (group addresses) to the others over the bus. If one device fails, the rest keep working. Devices are programmed with the ETS software, published by the KNX Association under a paid licence.
| Criterion | Loxone | KNX |
|---|---|---|
| Architecture | central: logic in the Miniserver | decentralised: every device independent |
| Manufacturers | one manufacturer (Loxone), with gateways to other systems | hundreds of manufacturers, one standard (EN 50090, ISO/IEC 14543-3) |
| Bus | Tree: data + 24 V in one cable | KNX TP: green bus cable, about 30 V, data + power |
| Programming | Loxone Config (the manufacturer’s software) | ETS (KNX Association, paid licence) |
| Smartphone control | the manufacturer’s app, part of the system | separate visualisation (server or display) |
| Who can take over | an installer familiar with Loxone, using the Config file | any KNX installer, using the ETS project |
| If one device fails | a Miniserver failure affects the whole system | only that one device stops |
KNX compared with wireless systems (when a radio-based smart home is enough, and what it costs): KNX or a wireless smart home?
What about Grenton and FIBARO?
Two more systems often appear in smart home quotes: Grenton and FIBARO. Both were developed by Polish companies, and both are single-manufacturer systems, like Loxone. The comparison below is based on the manufacturers’ own descriptions:
| Criterion | Loxone | KNX | Grenton | FIBARO |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Connection | wired (Tree), with wireless additions (Air) | wired bus cable (KNX TP) | hybrid: wired TF-Bus and Ethernet, complemented by Wi-Fi and Z-Wave modules | wireless: Z-Wave; the Home Center 3 hub also handles Wi-Fi, Zigbee and Nice devices |
| Central unit | Miniserver | none, decentralised | CLU (central unit) | Home Center 3 |
| Standard or proprietary | one manufacturer’s system | open standard (EN 50090, ISO/IEC 14543-3), hundreds of manufacturers | one manufacturer’s system with its own bus protocol (TF-Bus) | one manufacturer’s system; Z-Wave Plus certified devices from other manufacturers can be added |
| Programming | Loxone Config | ETS (paid licence) | Object Manager (Windows, macOS, Linux), without extra fees or licences according to the manufacturer | the Home Center 3 interface: block scenes or Lua scripts |
| Expandability | up to 50 devices and 500 m of cable per Tree branch | in lines, with KNX devices from any manufacturer | up to 48 modules (400 objects) and 300 m of bus per CLU; several CLUs can be linked over Ethernet | with wireless devices, without new bus cable |
| Typical use | new house, products from one manufacturer | new house or full renovation, for the long term | wired in a new house; in existing buildings with wireless modules, without opening walls, according to the manufacturer | retrofitting a lived-in flat or house |
Grenton is made by Grenton Sp. z o.o. of Kraków, which produces the system components at four locations in Poland. According to the manufacturer, its Distributed Logic keeps the system working even if the central unit is disconnected. FIBARO was founded in Poznań in 2010 and has belonged to the Italian Nice group since 2018. On the general strengths and limits of wireless systems: KNX or a wireless smart home?
When Loxone, and when KNX?
Loxone fits well if you…
- want switches, control, lights and app from a single manufacturer, with a consistent look;
- have complex house logic (many conditions, scenes, timers) and want to see it in one place, in one programme;
- accept that extensions and replacements stay within the manufacturer’s range.
KNX fits well if you…
- plan the house for 20–30 years and want any device to be replaceable by another manufacturer’s product;
- want any KNX installer to be able to continue the work, not only the one who built it;
- would like design switches from a major switch manufacturer (Gira, Jung, Berker, Merten and others).
KNX manufacturers: Gira, MDT and others
The advantage of KNX is that devices from several manufacturers can work in one house. Two common names:
- Gira: a German switch and KNX manufacturer. In the System 55 range a conventional switch and a KNX push-button (pushbutton sensor 4) fit the same 55 × 55 mm frame system, with more than 90 frame variants according to the manufacturer. A “Gira switch” can therefore be a simple 230 V switch or a KNX push-button in the same style.
- MDT: a German manufacturer (Engelskirchen) that has made only KNX products since 2009: actuators, sensors and push-buttons, including glass push-buttons. Some MDT push-buttons fit the 55 frames of other manufacturers (such as Gira, Berker, Jung, Merten).
A common, proven setup: actuators from one manufacturer in the board, design switches from another on the wall. In ETS this is a single project, and any device can later be replaced by a third manufacturer’s product. On building a KNX system: KNX smart home.
Cabling: what to decide before plastering
The power side is similar for both systems: every controlled circuit (light, blind, heating valve) runs on its own cable to the distribution board, where the relay, dimmer or blind actuator sits. The difference is on the low-voltage side:
- Loxone: Tree cable to push-buttons, sensors and Tree lights, divided into branches within the manufacturer’s length and device limits.
- KNX: green KNX bus cable to every push-button and sensor, within the line lengths of the standard.
- Both: a larger distribution board (for the DIN-rail devices), a network cable to the controller, and conduit to places that will be extended later. On conduits: which conduit goes where.
Later, cable is the most expensive item; in advance, the cheapest. If the full system does not fit the budget yet, the preparation (cable, conduit, larger board) still pays off.
What to ask your installer for
- A decision on the system at the start of the design, because the bus cable and the size of the board depend on it.
- A function list per room: what switches, dims, moves and measures, and what you want to see on your phone.
- The project file handed over: the Config file for Loxone, the ETS project for KNX, together with the passwords. It belongs to the client.
- An allocation list: which output switches which circuit, which push-button controls what.
- A UPS for the controller and the bus power supply if the system must restart quickly after a power cut.
More: KNX smart home · KNX or a wireless smart home? · Smart home remote access, KNX Secure
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between Loxone and KNX?
Loxone is one manufacturer’s system, with the logic running in a central controller, the Miniserver. KNX is an open standard with hundreds of manufacturers and no central unit: every device works independently. Both are wired, and we install both.
What is the Loxone Miniserver?
The central controller of a Loxone system, mounted on a DIN rail in the distribution board. The house logic runs in it, the Tree and wireless devices connect to it, and the smartphone app works through it.
What is Loxone Tree?
Loxone’s own wired bus: one cable carries data and 24 V power to push-buttons, sensors and lights. According to the manufacturer, one branch may have at most 50 devices and 500 m of cable, less with high-power loads.
Can Loxone be connected to KNX?
Yes. For the second-generation Miniserver the manufacturer offers a separate KNX extension, through which KNX devices can be integrated into the Loxone system.
Can Gira and MDT KNX devices be mixed?
Yes. Both are KNX devices, they can be programmed in one ETS project, and some MDT push-buttons fit Gira’s 55 frames.
What are Grenton and FIBARO, and how do they differ from Loxone or KNX?
Both are single-manufacturer systems, like Loxone. Grenton is hybrid: a wired TF-Bus and Ethernet backbone complemented by Wi-Fi and Z-Wave modules, with the CLU as central unit. FIBARO is a wireless, Z-Wave-based system with the Home Center 3 hub, part of the Nice group since 2018. KNX, by contrast, is an open standard with hundreds of manufacturers.
How much does a Loxone or KNX smart home cost?
It depends on the number of functions, controlled circuits and blinds, and the type of switches. Indicative ranges for KNX: KNX or a wireless smart home?; we quote individually based on the plans or a site survey. Price ranges by system: How much does a smart home cost in 2026?
Let’s talk about your project.
Tell us what you are planning and we will get back to you within a few days.
Get in touch