KNOWLEDGE BASE · SMART HOME

Smart thermostat or room-by-room heating control? Radiators, underfloor heating, heat pumps, KNX

A smart thermostat usually switches the boiler or heat pump on the temperature of one room; the other rooms just follow. Room-by-room control measures and holds the temperature in every room separately: with thermostatic valves or smart radiator thermostats on radiators, with room thermostats and actuators on underfloor heating, and in a KNX house as one system for all heating. In a new house in Hungary this is not just about comfort: the regulation requires it for rooms larger than 12 m².

In short

  • Smart thermostat: measures in one place and switches the heat generator. Can be enough for an open-plan flat, but cannot keep different temperatures in several rooms.
  • Radiators: a thermostatic valve regulates by itself, without power; a smart radiator thermostat fits in the same place and adds schedules and remote control.
  • Underfloor heating: a room thermostat plus actuators on the manifold. It is a slow system, so a good controller anticipates instead of just switching on and off.
  • KNX: every room gets its own controller, with shared operating modes (comfort, standby, night, frost protection), window contacts and demand-based control of the heat generator.
  • Mandatory? In Hungary, Decree 9/2023 (V. 25.) ÉKM requires independently adjustable temperature in every room over 12 m² when a new building gets a new heating system.

Author: Norbert Madarász, Managing Director and Partner · Updated: 10 November 2026

Smart thermostat or room-by-room control: what is the difference?

A classic room thermostat and most smart thermostats do the same thing: they measure the temperature in one room (the reference room) and start or stop the boiler or heat pump accordingly. The smart version adds an app, schedules and remote access. The other rooms measure nothing; they simply receive heat.

Room-by-room control, in contrast, means a separate sensor and a separate actuator (valve, actuator motor) in every heated room. The bedroom can stay cooler, the bathroom warmer, and in a sunny living room the valve throttles back by itself when the sun comes in.

AspectThermostatic valveSmart radiator thermostatKNX room control
What it controlsone radiator, by itselfone radiator, with schedulesevery room, radiators and underfloor heating
Powernone neededbatteriesKNX bus, 230 V or 24 V for the actuators
Cablingnonenone (radio, often via a hub)bus cable to the room sensors, wiring to the actuators
Schedules, away modenoyes, from the appyes, central, for every room
Open windownot detectedmany models watch for a sudden temperature dropfrom a window contact, immediately
Heat generator controlnoonly within its own systemyes, based on room demand
Best forevery radiator, as a baselinefinished flats, retrofitnew build or full renovation

Radiator thermostat: thermostatic valve or smart radiator thermostat?

A thermostatic radiator valve has two parts: the valve body on the radiator and the thermostatic head screwed onto it. The sensor in the head expands or contracts with the room temperature and closes or opens the valve accordingly. It needs no power, batteries or setup, which makes it the simplest form of room-by-room control.

A smart radiator thermostat is a battery-powered motorised head that replaces the existing thermostatic head. It moves the same valve, but adds schedules, remote control, often open-window detection and heating statistics. A few things are worth checking first:

  • Valve connection: the head must fit the existing valve body; according to the manufacturers’ compatibility lists an adapter is often needed.
  • Batteries and radio: batteries need replacing over time, and the radio link must reach every part of the house. Many systems need a hub.
  • The boiler does not know: if the smart heads are not linked to the heat generator, the boiler or heat pump keeps heating even when every valve is closed.

In a finished, occupied flat, smart radiator thermostats are a quick solution without chasing walls. In a new house or a full renovation, however, wiring a hard-wired system now is cheaper than swapping battery heads later.

Underfloor heating thermostat: how is it controlled room by room?

With underfloor heating, every room gets one or more loops on the manifold. Thermoelectric actuators open and close the loops on the command of the underfloor heating thermostat (or KNX room sensor) in the room. The actuators come in 230 V or 24 V versions and are typically normally closed.

  • Slow system: the screed stores heat for hours, so a simple on/off thermostat overshoots the set temperature.
  • PI control and PWM: a better controller (e.g. in a KNX heating actuator) calculates a valve opening ratio from the temperature deviation and its trend over time, and keeps the actuator open for the corresponding share of each cycle (pulse-width modulation). According to the manufacturer’s manual, the full stroke time of underfloor heating actuators is typically 2.5–3 minutes, which must be taken into account when setting the cycle.
  • Bathroom: there is often an electric towel rail or floor warming as well; plan them together with the room control.

Heat pumps and room-by-room control: what to watch out for?

A heat pump is most efficient with low flow temperatures and steady operation. Room control does not contradict this, but the two have to be coordinated:

  • Minimum flow rate: the heat pump needs the water flow specified by its manufacturer. If every loop closes at once, it is not met; the heating designer sizes the hydraulics (buffer tank, bypass loop, balancing) for this.
  • Hydronic balancing: Directive (EU) 2024/1275 requires hydronic balancing, where appropriate, together with room-by-room control. In a balanced system the valves work against each other less often.
  • Demand-based control: with KNX, the valve positions of the rooms show how much heat is needed; this can be passed on to the heat pump controller (through an interface the manufacturer supports, e.g. Modbus or a KNX gateway).

For the heat pump’s electrical connection, its own circuit and coordination with a PV system, see our page heat pump and solar electrical connection.

KNX heating control: what can a KNX house do?

In a KNX house, heating runs in the same system as lighting and shading. Each room has a temperature sensor (often built into the wall pushbutton), a controller (in the pushbutton, the heating actuator or a separate device) and the actuator: a KNX valve drive on radiators, or for underfloor heating a heating actuator in the distribution board that switches the actuators on the manifold.

  • Operating modes: comfort, standby, night and frost protection, each with its own setpoint. One button puts the house into “away” mode, and every room switches to its own value.
  • Window contact: with the window open, the room switches to frost protection and does not heat the street.
  • Presence and schedules: the guest room only heats when in use; the bathroom is already warm in the morning.
  • Emergency mode: a good heating actuator can be set to keep heating with a fixed valve position if the temperature value stops arriving for a while (e.g. a faulty sensor), so the room does not cool down.
  • Cooling too: the same system also handles cooling (e.g. underfloor cooling with a heat pump), with dew point monitoring.

Our managing director has also completed the KNX HVAC Specialist course on heating, cooling and ventilation control; we design the KNX system together with the heating. More: KNX smart home · Decision guide: KNX or wireless smart home?

Is room-by-room control mandatory in a new house?

In Hungary, in most cases, yes. According to point 3.2.2 of Annex 1 to Decree 9/2023 (V. 25.) ÉKM (on determining the energy performance of buildings), when a new heating and cooling system is installed, a new building must be equipped with self-regulating devices that allow the temperature to be adjusted independently in every room with a floor area over 12 m². In existing buildings these devices must be installed when the heat generator and heat emitters are replaced, if they can be fitted without reworking the distribution and emission system.

The decree transposes the EU directive on the energy performance of buildings; the current version, Directive (EU) 2024/1275, requires the same in Article 13(3). In Germany, § 63 of the GModG (the successor of the GEG) requires automatic room-by-room control for water-based heating. A thermostatic valve is itself such a self-regulating device; the law does not require KNX or smart heads, these are decisions about comfort and energy saving.

This article is general information, not legal advice. The requirements for a specific building are confirmed by the building services engineer and the energy designer in the energy calculation.

Which one to choose, and what to decide before plastering?

  1. Finished flat with radiators: a thermostatic valve on every radiator, smart radiator thermostats if wanted, and a smart thermostat for the heat generator. No chasing walls.
  2. New house or full renovation without KNX: a wired underfloor heating thermostat in every room, cable to the manifold; we plan the thermostat positions together with the furniture (not in direct sun, not above a radiator).
  3. New house with KNX: bus cable to every room sensor (often built into the pushbutton), wiring to the manifold cabinets for the heating actuator, and window contact cables before the windows are installed.
  4. Heat pump: coordinate room control and hydraulics with the heating designer before the positions of the manifold and buffer tank are fixed.
We handle the electrical and KNX side (cabling, actuators, programming); the heating system is designed and installed by the building services contractor. Individual quote after a site survey or based on the plans.

More: KNX smart home · Smart home · Heat pump and solar connection · Electrical installation

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a smart thermostat and room-by-room control?

A smart thermostat measures in one room and switches the boiler or heat pump. Room-by-room control measures in every room and moves a separate valve or actuator, so rooms can be kept at different temperatures.

What does a thermostatic radiator valve do?

It keeps the room temperature by itself, without power: the sensor in the head closes or opens the valve according to the temperature. It is the simplest form of room-by-room control.

Is a smart radiator thermostat worth it?

In a finished flat, yes: it adds schedules and remote control without chasing walls. It is worth most when linked to the heat generator; otherwise the boiler keeps heating even when every valve is closed.

Which thermostat does underfloor heating need?

One underfloor heating thermostat or KNX room sensor per room, controlling the actuators on the manifold. Because the screed reacts slowly, proportional (PI) control is more accurate than on/off switching.

Is room-by-room control mandatory in a new house in Hungary?

Under Decree 9/2023 (V. 25.) ÉKM, when a new building gets a new heating and cooling system, the temperature must be independently adjustable in every room over 12 m². A thermostatic valve counts as such a self-regulating device.

Does room-by-room control work with a heat pump?

Yes, but the minimum water flow specified by the heat pump manufacturer must be met even when many loops are closed. The heating designer solves this in the hydraulics (buffer tank, balancing).

Let’s talk about your project.

Tell us what you are planning and we will get back to you within a few days.

Get in touch

Cookie settings

Choose what you consent to. We remember your choice for 6 months; change it any time via “Cookie settings” in the footer.

Privacy notice