Smart relay, smart switch or smart bulb? Retrofitting with Shelly, Home Assistant and Philips Hue
There are three ways to make an existing house smart without opening walls: a smart relay behind the existing switch (such as Shelly), a smart wall switch in place of the old one, or a smart bulb in the light (such as Philips Hue). All three work, but each asks for something different: the relay and the switch are 230 V electrical work, while with a bulb the wall switch must always stay on. This article helps you decide which suits your house, and when you need a hub such as Home Assistant.
In short
- Smart relay behind the switch: the existing switch stays, a small module goes into the box. Most need a neutral wire; there are no-neutral versions with an add-on.
- Smart wall switch: replaces the old switch, with a display or touch surface. The same wiring conditions as the relay.
- Smart bulb (Philips Hue and others): no wiring, but the wall switch must not cut its power, otherwise the bulb cannot be reached.
- Wi-Fi or Zigbee: a Wi-Fi device connects to the router without a hub; Zigbee devices need a hub (coordinator), such as a Hue Bridge or Home Assistant with a Zigbee adapter.
- Home Assistant: worth it if you want to manage several brands on one interface, locally, without the cloud.
Author: Norbert Madarász
, Managing Director and Partner · Updated: 14 November 2026
Smart relay, smart switch, smart bulb: what is the difference?
| Solution | Where it goes | What it needs | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Smart relay (e.g. Shelly) | behind the existing switch, in the back box, or in the distribution board | neutral wire (or a no-neutral type), a deep enough box, a relay rated for the load | keeping the existing switches while controlling lights, blinds, heating |
| Smart wall switch | in place of the old switch | as for the relay, plus a size that fits the frame | when the switch is replaced anyway, with a display or touch surface |
| Smart bulb (e.g. Philips Hue) | in the light, in place of the old bulb | constant power: the wall switch must stay on | floor and table lamps, mood and colour lighting, rented flats |
The relay and the wall switch are 230 V wiring and should be installed by an electrician. Anyone can screw in a smart bulb; in return the light is smart but the wall switch stays “dumb”. A general comparison of wired and wireless systems: KNX or a wireless smart home?
Smart relay behind the switch: when do you need a neutral wire?
A relay behind the switch runs all the time, so it needs power even when the light is off. In older houses the switch box often contains only the live wire and the wire to the light, with no neutral.
- If there is a neutral in the box: most relay types can be fitted, chosen for the load according to the relay datasheet.
- If there is no neutral: you need a no-neutral type. The Shelly 1L Gen3, for example, works without a neutral, but with LED lights it requires a Bypass add-on in parallel with the light (included by the manufacturer), so the low-power LED does not flicker or glow when off.
- If the box is small or crowded: the relay and wires heat up; a deeper box is needed, or the relay goes on a DIN rail in the distribution board.
- Heavy loads (water heater, pump, heating): according to the relay rating, with a contactor in the board where necessary.
Wi-Fi, Zigbee or Matter: which one?
- Wi-Fi (e.g. most Shelly devices): no hub needed, the device connects to the home router. It is as good as the Wi-Fi: you need stable coverage everywhere in the house. On Wi-Fi: extender, mesh or access point.
- Zigbee (e.g. Philips Hue, Aqara, many Sonoff devices): a low-power radio on which battery sensors last for years. Mains-powered Zigbee devices relay the signal for each other (a mesh network), but a hub (coordinator) is needed: a Hue Bridge, a manufacturer hub, or Home Assistant with a Zigbee adapter.
- Matter: a common standard so that devices from different manufacturers can be controlled from one app. It runs over Wi-Fi or Thread radio; before buying, check that both the device and your chosen hub support it.
For a few devices Wi-Fi is simplest. For many sensors and battery devices Zigbee is better. If part of the house is already controlled by one brand, extending within that system is cheapest.
Do you need Home Assistant? The role of the hub
Shelly, Hue and most brands work with their own apps. Home Assistant is worth it if you want to see several brands on one interface, want complex automations (for example, heating off when a window is open), and want control to run locally, without the internet.
- Hardware: Home Assistant is also available as a dedicated box (Home Assistant Green). The Green has no Zigbee radio; for Zigbee devices a separate adapter is needed (the manufacturer recommends the Connect ZBT-2).
- Location: the hub goes into the low-voltage cabinet or next to the router, on a network cable, powered from a UPS.
- Maintenance: Home Assistant is updated regularly. At handover we show you what to check where, and the configuration is backed up.
The Philips Hue Bridge, Shelly and many other brands can be integrated into Home Assistant, so existing devices are not wasted.
Philips Hue: when a smart bulb is right, and when you need DALI or KNX
Philips Hue smart bulbs and lights communicate over Zigbee; the full feature set needs a Hue Bridge. According to the manufacturer, one Hue Bridge handles up to 50 lights and the larger Bridge Pro more than 150. Larger houses need several bridges or the Bridge Pro.
- The wall switch is the weak point: if someone switches it off, the bulb loses power and the app cannot reach it. The fix is Hue’s wireless wall switch, or a module behind the existing switch that turns it into a Hue button; the light circuit then stays permanently on.
- Where it fits: floor lamps, table lamps, mood and colour lighting, an LED strip behind the TV; in occupied houses and rented flats where nothing is opened up.
- Where it is not the right choice: new builds or full renovations with many built-in spots and LED strips. There, dimming is best done from the distribution board with DALI or KNX, with the wall switch part of the system. More: DALI lighting control, hidden LED lighting in drywall.
IKEA DIRIGERA, TRÅDFRI and EGLO connect.z: smart lights from the store
IKEA and EGLO smart lights work like Hue: the light needs permanent power, and the wall switch must not cut it.
- IKEA: TRÅDFRI devices use Zigbee, the hub is DIRIGERA. According to IKEA, DIRIGERA is both a Matter bridge and a Matter controller: IKEA devices can appear in Apple Home, Google Home or Alexa, and other makers' Matter devices can be added to DIRIGERA.
- EGLO connect.z: Zigbee 3.0 and Bluetooth in one light. Over Bluetooth it can be controlled from a phone without a hub; with a Zigbee hub (e.g. Home Assistant with a Zigbee adapter) it can be managed together with other smart devices.
- Wall switch: the existing switch is replaced by the IKEA or EGLO wireless switch, or a module goes behind it, so the light circuit stays on.
If part of the house already runs on IKEA or EGLO devices, there is no need to throw them away: they can be connected to Home Assistant or a Matter hub. In a new house with many built-in lights, wired control (DALI, KNX) is still the more durable choice.
When do you need to open walls after all?
- No neutral, and a no-neutral type will not do (for example the load is too small, or the light does not work with the Bypass): a wire has to be pulled to the box.
- Outdated wiring: aluminium conductors, circuits without earth, an old fuse board. The wiring has to be put right first; see electrical installation.
- Many functions in one place: if the goal is to control 30–40 circuits, blinds and heating zones, a wired system in the distribution board is clearer than modules hidden in walls. In a renovation it is worth looking at KNX preparation: KNX or a wireless smart home?
What to ask your electrician for
- A survey switch by switch: is there a neutral, how big is the box, what is the load, and how good is the Wi-Fi throughout the house.
- A device list: which relay goes behind which switch, where a Zigbee hub is needed, whether Home Assistant is needed.
- Wiring to standard on the 230 V side, with a relay rated for the load, in the distribution board where necessary.
- Documentation: which device is where, what it switches, and the access details.
Related articles from our knowledge base
Colours, frames, IP44, USB chargers, push-in terminals and smart versions from manufacturer catalogues.
Read →Public price ranges by system – Shelly, FIBARO, Home Assistant, Grenton, Loxone, KNX – and what drives the total.
Read →How they differ, whether you need a hub or a Thread border router, what a Matter bridge is, and when KNX or DALI is better.
Read →Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a smart relay and a smart switch?
A smart relay goes behind the existing switch, in the back box, and the switch stays. A smart wall switch replaces the old switch. The wiring condition is similar for both: most types need a neutral wire in the box.
Can a Shelly be wired without a neutral?
With a no-neutral type, yes, for example the Shelly 1L Gen3. With LED lights the manufacturer requires a Bypass add-on in parallel with the light, and includes it in the box. We check for a neutral during the survey.
Do I need Home Assistant for Shelly?
No: Shelly works with its own app. Home Assistant is a good choice if you want to manage and automate several brands on one interface, locally, without the cloud.
Does Home Assistant Green need a Zigbee adapter?
Only if you have Zigbee devices. Home Assistant Green has no Zigbee radio, so a separate adapter is needed; Wi-Fi and network devices work without one.
How many lights does a Philips Hue Bridge handle?
According to the manufacturer, the Hue Bridge handles up to 50 lights and the Hue Bridge Pro more than 150. Larger systems need several bridges or the Bridge Pro.
What happens to a smart bulb if I turn off the wall switch?
It loses power and the app cannot reach it. That is why it is worth replacing the wall switch with a wireless switch or a module behind the switch, so the light circuit stays on.
Can IKEA DIRIGERA be connected to Home Assistant or Apple Home?
Yes. According to IKEA, DIRIGERA is a Matter bridge, so the IKEA devices connected to it can appear in systems with a Matter controller (Apple Home, Google Home, Alexa, Home Assistant).
Does an EGLO connect.z light need a hub?
Not necessarily: over Bluetooth it can be controlled from a phone without a hub. To use it with other smart devices and automations, a Zigbee hub is needed.
Let’s talk about your project.
Tell us what you are planning and we will get back to you within a few days.
Get in touch